Ratio Decidendi and Obiter Dictum: A Curious Case
暫譯: 判決理由與附帶意見：一個好奇的案例
Mitidiero, Daniel
- 出版商: Springer
- 出版日期: 2025-06-15
- 售價: $6,440
- 貴賓價: 9.5 折 $6,118
- 語言: 英文
- 頁數: 151
- 裝訂: Hardcover - also called cloth, retail trade, or trade
- ISBN: 3031931513
- ISBN-13: 9783031931512
海外代購書籍(需單獨結帳)
相關主題
商品描述
This book explores the concepts of ratio decidendi and obiter dictum from a historical-comparative perspective. It provides a comprehensive review of legal doctrine on precedent, delving into English and American Law so to illustrate its applicability to the Brazilian legal system. How we deal with precedents is its main topic.
Definitions within legal fields have always been subject to significant debate, with some recurring more often than others. Every now and then, a perspective arises which transforms the orthodoxy. As such is the case with the notion of precedent. Outlining its contours establishes a continuity between disparate and temporally distinct traditions. It requires theoretical-philosophical speculation, historical-comparative sense, and attention to the particularities of Brazilian Law.
This book includes in-depth discussions of the development of the various understandings of the ratio, outlines the notions of ratio decidendi and obiter dictum, and illustrates its application within legal practice. It suggests an understating of the ratio capable of dealing with identical, similar and distinct issues in the Brazilian legal system. Following an extensive debate on the characterisation of the ratio, it explores the notion of obiter dictum, its definition, abilities and effects.
The target audience of this book includes researchers, scholars and practitioners, especially those interested in the practice of precedent from a perspective that intertwines legal theory, legal history and comparative law.
商品描述(中文翻譯)
本書從歷史比較的角度探討了判決理由（ratio decidendi）和附帶意見（obiter dictum）的概念。它對法律先例的法律學說進行了全面的回顧，深入探討英美法，以說明其在巴西法律體系中的適用性。我們如何處理先例是本書的主要主題。
法律領域內的定義一直受到重大爭論，有些定義的討論頻率高於其他定義。時不時會出現一種觀點，改變了傳統的正統觀念。判例的概念就是這樣的情況。勾勒其輪廓建立了不同且時間上各異的傳統之間的連續性。這需要理論哲學的推測、歷史比較的理解，以及對巴西法律特點的關注。
本書深入討論了各種對判決理由的理解的發展，概述了判決理由和附帶意見的概念，並說明其在法律實踐中的應用。它建議一種能夠處理巴西法律體系中相同、相似和不同問題的判決理由的理解。在對判決理由的特徵進行廣泛討論後，本書探討了附帶意見的概念、定義、能力和影響。
本書的目標讀者包括研究人員、學者和實務工作者，特別是那些對從法律理論、法律歷史和比較法交織的角度研究先例實踐感興趣的人。
作者簡介
Daniel Mitidiero is an Associate Professor of Civil Procedure at the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (since 2011). He holds a PhD in Law from UFRGS (2007) and has been a Visiting Scholar at the University of Edinburgh, Scotland (2023) and the University of Pavia, Italy (2013).
He is a member of the Council of the International Association of Procedural Law (IAPL), the Instituto Iberoamericano de Derecho Procesal (IIDP), the Associazione Italiana fra gli Studiosi del Processo Civile (AISPC), the Asociación Argentina de Derecho Procesal (AADP), and serves on the Board of the Instituto Brasileiro de Direito Processual (IBDP).
Daniel is the author of numerous books and articles published internationally. Additionally, he is a practising lawyer in Brazil.
作者簡介(中文翻譯)
丹尼爾·米提迪耶羅（Daniel Mitidiero）是巴西南大河州聯邦大學（Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul）的民事訴訟副教授（自2011年起）。他於2007年獲得UFRGS的法學博士學位，並曾於2023年在蘇格蘭愛丁堡大學（University of Edinburgh）和2013年在意大利帕維亞大學（University of Pavia）擔任訪問學者。
他是國際訴訟法協會（International Association of Procedural Law, IAPL）、伊比利亞美洲訴訟法研究所（Instituto Iberoamericano de Derecho Procesal, IIDP）、意大利民事訴訟研究學會（Associazione Italiana fra gli Studiosi del Processo Civile, AISPC）、阿根廷訴訟法協會（Asociación Argentina de Derecho Procesal, AADP）的成員，並在巴西訴訟法研究所（Instituto Brasileiro de Direito Processual, IBDP）擔任董事會成員。
丹尼爾是多部國際出版的書籍和文章的作者。此外，他也是巴西的一名執業律師。
